The ordinary person, faced with the myriad wonders coming out of astronomy every day (and night), can either believe them or not. Without the scientist's apparatus of physics and mathematics there is simply no way to tell whether the story is quite certain, a reasonable guess---or a tall tale. Until now. I review the work of several famous astronomers, writing for the public, with a critical eye, holding them firmly to account. I point out oversimplifications, missing steps in logic, unfairness in argument and other faults. Further, I explain lapses in science and mathematics in a way understandable to those with no background in either (though, if you pay attention, you'll have quite a bit at the end!). My object is to give layman tools by which uncertain results can be detected---or at least doubts raised about them. Along the way I set out some guidelines for scientists themselves, to check their work and especially how they present it to the public. This is a unique book. It is not straight history, nor an exposition of astronomy itself, nor a meditation on the philosophy of science. It is an attempt to answer the question, ``How far can you trust a scientist?'' |
|
Dramatis Personae
Authors I examine include
|